Fords have way more than their share of timing belt trouble but I haven't heard anything specific to the Focus. The Contour and Mystique are notorious for chewing up their belts. The belts do wear out over time, and some just snap, but it is common also for the bearings to become sloppy in the idler pulleys and tensioner pulleys. When the belt becomes loose, it can jump a tooth or two. One tooth off will definitely be noticeable as a loss of power and throttle response.
It is real hard for a belt to jump on a Chrysler product because the cover is so close to the crankshaft sprocket that the belt can't lift up off the sprocket teeth far enough to jump. They also have controls built into the Engine Computer that will shut the engine down before the belt can jump enough teeth for the pistons hit the valves. The problem is they have more trouble with the sensors than the belt.
I haven't heard about Ford doing something similar but I would have to guess they don't have that protection because I read a lot about bent valves on their engines. To get back to the engine damage issue, valves are very easy to bend. It takes a lot to bend a connecting rod or punch a hole in a piston. To put it in perspective, if the timing belt is not installed correctly, you can bend valves by turning the engine by hand. To bend a connecting rod will require a hammer significantly heavier than your typical carpenter's hammer. The pistons are pretty tough too. They get pounded with rapidly expanding fuel millions of times every month and come back for more. A sad little weak valve isn't going to phase it. Unless the steel head of the valve breaks off, (very rare except for NASCAR engines), and gets stuck, that valve is going to be nothing more than an irritation to the piston.
To recommend replacing the entire engine, your mechanic is either 1) inexperienced in engine repair, 2) setting you up for the worst case scenario, then hoping to pleasantly surprise you with a much lower bill if it only needs a valve job, 3) doesn't want to be bothered by the care and accuracy that must be taken when reassembling a cylinder head, or 4) justs wants to produce a bigger bill. A used engine could just as likely have a worn timing belt too so you might have the same problem a month from now. Unless you hear about some common "pattern failure" that happens often to your engine, a valve job which includes a new head gasket, and a new timing belt should be all that's needed. If the water pump is one of the idler pulleys, it is customary to replace it too to prevent future trouble. It is just as big a job to replace the water pump as the timing belt, so you might as well do it while you're already there.
Caradiodoc
Tuesday, April 4th, 2017 AT 1:56 PM
(Merged)