2000 BMW 528 Blown Head Gasket
Don't know about yopur quote as i'm in Aus but it does sound a bit stiff. As for only a blown head gasket, it might not be as simple as that. BMW's along with just about every other canr on the road has an alloy cyl head. When over heated these heads are known to bend and crack. Now this is not as bad as it sounds as it is a comon problem and easly fixed. When the head is removed they should do a vacuum test on the combustion chambers, this will give an indication to the condition of the falve seats, and if extra work is required. Normaly a wet & dry compression test is a good indication as to the condition of the valves. A small anountv of oil in added to the cyl and a compression test done, if the compression rises a ring problem is indicated if there is little or no differance in reading a valve is at fault. This test is not sutable when a head gasket is suspected.
Good luck.
Mark (mhpautos)
Suggested Repair
Treat the $5,000 quote as possibly high and get a second opinion. Do not assume it is only a head gasket: overheating can warp or crack an alloy cylinder head. When the head is removed, have the combustion chambers vacuum-tested for valve-seat condition. A wet-and-dry compression test can help check valves, but it is not suitable while a head gasket failure is suspected.
Conversation Summary
A low-mileage 2000 BMW 528 overheated, produced a foul odor, and had sludgy coolant with oil in it but no water in the oil. A dealership said the valves checked out and quoted about $5,000 for a suspected blown head gasket, or up to $8,000 if a valve was needed. The expert said the quote sounded high, warned that an overheated alloy head can bend or crack, and recommended vacuum testing the combustion chambers after head removal rather than relying on a wet-and-dry compression test.
