Hi,
I had a feeling it was the starter. As far as your choices, I personally like to buy new parts. As far as the refurbished OEM starter, remember it is now a re-manufactured part and will only be a good as the person that rebuilt it. If I had to choose between the two, I would get the new one.
If you want to try doing it yourself, here is a link that shows in general how it's done. It really isn't hard to do. Just make sure the battery is disconnected before you start working on it.
https://www.2carpros.com/articles/how-to-replace-a-starter-motor
______________________________________________
Here are the directions specific to your vehicle. The attached pictures correlate with the directions.
2009 Honda Accord L4-2.4L
Removal and Replacement
Vehicle Starting and Charging Starting System Starter Motor Service and Repair Removal and Replacement
REMOVAL AND REPLACEMENT
Starter Removal and Installation
Removal
1. Do the battery removal procedure. See: Battery > Removal and Replacement
2. Remove the intake manifold.
3. Disconnect the positive starter cable (A) and the S terminal connector (B).
4. Remove the harness clamp (C).
pic 1
5. Remove the two bolts (A) securing the starter, then remove the starter.
pic 2
Installation
1. Install the starter, then tighten the two bolts.
pic 3
2. Install the harness clamp (A).
pic 4
3. Connect the positive starter cable (B) and the S terminal connector (C). Make sure the crimped side of the ring terminal faces away from the starter when you connect it.
4. Install the intake manifold.
5. Do the battery installation procedure. See: Battery > Removal and Replacement
6. Start the engine to make sure the starter works properly.
_______________
If you do it yourself, I'm here if you have questions or need help.
Take care,
Joe
Images (Click to make bigger)
Wednesday, September 30th, 2020 AT 12:13 PM
(Merged)