That would do it. If even one injector is dumping fuel it will signal that the engine is running rich and try to lean it out. You mentioned some cleaner in the fuel, it's possible the cleaner did it's job and flushed the dirt out of the system and it got stuck in the injector and is preventing it from sealing, It would still click and open but because of the fuel pressure even being open half the thickness of a hair will cause it to flood out.
However as the injector you pulled has the wrong number it's likely a combination of things all coming together. The plugs you put up earlier all showed signs of running rich an if the problem was only the single cylinder then only that cylinder would be carbon coated. At this point I would opt for replacing the injectors, If you had a way to flow test them I'd go that way but a flow bench isn't a common item in most places. Plus with the cost of a set of 4 new injectors the testing would cost more than replacing.
SPONSORED LINKS
Monday, December 14th, 2020 AT 4:24 PM