I brought the car in about a week ago due to some misfires in cylinders 1, 3, and 4. The mechanic, who is very trusted, did a compression test and said that the 3rd cylinder basically had no compression, only 50 lbs. The 1st and 4th had 200 lbs, while the 2nd had 150. He said that the 3rd cylinder was likely causing the other two to misfire due to non combusted materials pushing back up into the intake.
The mechanic said it was probably a valve problem, and though I've asked him several times he insists it is probably not a head gasket. I agree that I don't see any other symptoms of a head gasket problem. The engine was too old for any valve repairs to do much good without causing other problems, he said. He told me to try, as a last ditch effort, various engine cleaning products.
I tried a number of those, and the engine began to run much more smoothly. Whereas before it would hiccup during acceleration, the acceleration was now near perfect, and there was a lot more power than there had been. The car also ran smoother while driving it.
However, the idle performance of the car got worse. I lost about 200 RPMs off of what was already a low idle. As of today, it now stalls anytime it is not being given gas, but seems to run fine when it is getting gas. Even before I saw the mechanic, the misfires seemed not to occur when giving the engine gas.
So I am trying to figure out #1) why it would have misfired only on idle if the compression on that cylinder was really that bad, in other words, if something caused the compression to be better when getting gas, and #2) what could have happened that would cause the engine to operate more smoothly after being cleaned but at the same time to lose idle RPMs and now to stall altogether.
Thanks!
Thursday, May 7th, 2020 AT 1:06 PM
(Merged)