Using HEI ignition swap from Chrysler's ignition?

Tiny
ITBROKE
  • MEMBER
  • 1977 CHRYSLER NEWPORT
  • 6.6L
  • V8
  • 2WD
  • AUTOMATIC
  • 63,000 MILES
My vehicle is seldom driven. I am getting frustrated with how it eats up ignition modules. How long should they last anyway? The replaced modules are grounded to clean metal where the original one was. I am considering a swap to an older GM module since they have good reviews. Maybe the bad reviews aren't talked about. Am I on the right track to solve this problem? The lean burn system on this car has been removed so it would be more like a 1976. With the price of these modules now, maybe I should opt for an economy car like a Rolls.
Friday, April 7th, 2023 AT 9:00 PM

9 Replies

Tiny
CARADIODOC
  • MECHANIC
  • 33,916 POSTS
I've only had one Lean Burn failure. That was on one of my cars, and it turned out to be a sensor problem, not the computer. The engine ran fine but no timing advance ever got introduced. I figured that out after doing a similar modification.

You aren't going to get an HEI distributor to fit on your engine, The original systems had their own set of problems including "punch through" and shorting of the rotors, pickup coil failures, and module failures. Later versions also added a computer that caused a real lot of trouble all through the 1980s and early '90s. They're the reason so many people today think a new computer will solve everything. The better alternative is to switch to the world's first electronic ignition system which was used on 1972 Dodges and 1973 Chryslers and Plymouths. The distributor is a drop-in replacement and is identical to the one you'll be removing, but it has the mechanical and vacuum advance mechanisms built in. Run the vacuum hose from the Lean Burn Computer to the advance unit on the distributor. Bolt on the 5-pin ignition module, add the very trouble-prone dual ballast resistor, (and carry a spare in the glove box). In keeping with Chrysler's excellent parts interchangeability, the distributor cap and rotor are the same. If you want to pursue this, I will draw up the diagram and instructions for you.

What happened that makes you think the Lean Burn Computers are failing? What were the symptoms?
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Saturday, April 8th, 2023 AT 11:40 AM
Tiny
ITBROKE
  • MEMBER
  • 64 POSTS
Thank you for your prompt reply. As I said in my first comment about my problem, the lean burn computer etc, is gone and was replaced by a previous owner to what might be considered a 1976 Chrysler. In my case, I have no lean burn system. It is gone.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Saturday, April 8th, 2023 AT 12:02 PM
Tiny
CARADIODOC
  • MECHANIC
  • 33,916 POSTS
What is running the engine now? Does it have the five-pin ignition module? If it does, look at the plug and / or the pins in the module itself to see if there's all five wires and terminals or if only four are there. I have two 1980 Volares. Both have just four wires. I did this modification on a 1978 LeBaron wagon. That one came with the Lean Burn system.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Saturday, April 8th, 2023 AT 12:12 PM
Tiny
ITBROKE
  • MEMBER
  • 64 POSTS
It has 4 pins.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Saturday, April 8th, 2023 AT 12:17 PM
Tiny
CARADIODOC
  • MECHANIC
  • 33,916 POSTS
So you have the newer version of that ignition module. I apologize that I had the Lean Burn system loaded up in my mind. Do you have a dual ballast resistor on the firewall? If it is there and was wired as the original ones were, one side of each resistor will be fed with a dark blue wire. One wire feeds them, then a short jumper wire connects to the second resistor. There could also be just a regular single ballast resistor. The second one was eliminated when they went to the 4-pin module.

How are these modules failing? What symptoms do they cause? Does the distributor have the vacuum advance mechanism on it?
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Saturday, April 8th, 2023 AT 1:32 PM
Tiny
ITBROKE
  • MEMBER
  • 64 POSTS
A module might be suspected when the engine cranks for longer than it should. Then I get
under the hood, take off the first spark plug wire and check for spark. If there is no spark, then from past experience, it is most likely the module. The car has a 2-pole resistor that reads 3.2 ohms. I`m beginning to wonder if this is too high. The ignition module is shaped like the Chrysler Pentastar emblem. The long mid point wire is blue yellow, the point clockwise is blk white, then brnwht, then unused and last blkyellow. The distributor has the vacuum advance and pickup coil, no points. In the past I have kept some of the old modules that started to fail but still fired the engine. They were a quick check when a module quit, cause an old one could be dropped in and firing might start again. I have run out of these old ones. I`m not that particularly nostalgic about this ignition system that in this last failure, could have stranded me 20 miles from home. In 2019 the module cost about $40. Now it's about $92. So with this novel I have written is the case for a change of ignition to the GM HEI module that can be seen on YouTube.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Saturday, April 8th, 2023 AT 7:35 PM
Tiny
CARADIODOC
  • MECHANIC
  • 33,916 POSTS
This isn't a solution, but look on Rock Auto under 1980 Volare. They have them listed from two suppliers for less than $17.00. That's less than the $25.00 I saw locally a few years ago in a hardware store.

Something else is going on to cause these failures. The best suspect I can think of is a voltage spike. If you're checking for spark at the ignition coil's wire, you'll see you get a spark when the ignition switch is turned off. That's because the module's switching transistor, (that's what you see that looks like a stack of nickels held on with two screws), is switched on to cause current flow to build a huge magnetic field in the ignition coil. When that current is switched off, either by breaker points, the electronic module's transistor, or by the ignition switch, that magnetic field collapses instantly and is what generates the very high spark voltage. As a point of interest, if that switching transistor is shorted, you won't have spark during cranking, but you will see that one spark at the ignition coil when a helper turns the ignition switch off.

The first thing I would suspect is a missing capacitor, especially seeing as how this is a retrofit. Those are used with breaker points to reduce arcing across those contacts, but you'll also find them with electronic ignition systems to dampen these voltage spikes. My online diagrams don't go back far enough, so Ill have to look at home in my service manual for my Volares. That will tell us if there could be a capacitor missing.

The only other thing to look for is there's a fifth electrical connection. That is where the module's housing is bolted to the inner fender. Check if those bolts are tight and not rusty. A less-than-perfect ground there can cause a voltage to develop there that back-feeds into other circuits.

The 3.2 ohms you found sounds about right. As I recall with the dual resistor, one was around half an ohm and the other was almost ten times higher. I don't know which of those got eliminated when they went to the four-pin module
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Sunday, April 9th, 2023 AT 8:11 PM
Tiny
ITBROKE
  • MEMBER
  • 64 POSTS
Have you heard of anyone who has used the GM HEI ignition modules in a swap to improve starting?
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Monday, April 10th, 2023 AT 8:50 AM
Tiny
CARADIODOC
  • MECHANIC
  • 33,916 POSTS
Nope. My experience with GM is they like to build and sell assemblies. This includes their very nice '86 and older generators with the built-in voltage regulator, and their HEI distributors with the built-in ignition module and ignition coil. As stated by one of their representatives in a training class, they do that because their dealership mechanics didn't know how these systems worked when they were introduced. These items are a simple drop-in replacement. With the HEI distributor, you just plug in one 12-volt wire, along with the spark plug wires, and you're done. A few years later it took the aftermarket suppliers to come up with individual replacement parts, tools, and the instructions to repair these assemblies rather than replace them.

Most other manufacturers design and sell the individual parts, such as Chrysler's alternator and separate voltage regulator. You just buy the part that needs to be replaced, not the entire assembly.

If the ignition system is working properly, changing to a different system won't affect how quickly the engine starts. In the case of my Volare, since the day it was brand new, if I'd run it every day, it always fired right up, including after sitting for a week over Christmas break, then leaving for college when it was 30 degrees below 0 F. If it sat longer than that, the gas would evaporate out of the float bowl. That resulted in a long crank time of up to five seconds. There is a service bulletin to address that, and I have the part, but never bothered to install it. That had nothing to do with spark. Once that engine was run for the first time that day, it started so quickly the next time that you can barely even hear the starter motor.

When it comes to retrofitting a part from a different manufacturer, the only thing I've ever seen is using a Chrysler starter on a GM race engine. GM and Ford starters are direct drive and draw around 300 amps to get started spinning, then they drop down to around 200 amps. That's for a typical passenger car engine. With the high compression of race engines, it was too difficult for those starters to crank the engines, so they retrofitted a Chrysler starter which has a gear reduction assembly. They draw closer to 150 amps when spinning. In later years, either GM or the aftermarket suppliers developed a high-torque starter so the Chrysler swap was no longer necessary.

As far as swapping distributors, I can share what I know, not that it will help. First you have to look at the length of the body, and whether it's the right length to reach the camshaft. Next is the diameter where it bolts to on the hole in the block. There will be an o-ring around it to keep oil from leaking out. The biggest issue is the drive gear. GMs use a helical gear that meshes with a gear cast as part of the camshaft. It can be installed with that shaft in about two dozen orientations. Chrysler distributors have what looks like a flat-blade screwdriver on the end of the shaft. It can go into its drive gear one of two ways. That drive gear meshes with the drive gear on the end of the camshaft, but it also has a long shaft that goes down to run the oil pump. That shaft isn't part of GM's drive system.

There may be kits out there to do this type of modification, but I've never looked into this myself. Be aware too there's three different distributor applications. I've only had one from a "big block" 440 c.I. The 426 and the 426 Hemi use one with a slightly longer shaft. Your 400 c.I. And all the other big blocks use one with a shorter shaft. The small block V-8s including up to the 360 c.I. Use a different distributor. I don't know how they compare to those first two. The six-cylinder distributors are very different and not part of this wondrous story.

If this modification is something you are able to pursue, I would recommend looking for an early version with the vacuum advance units built in. Those without on the newer models used a separate computer module to create timing advance. Those computers would require you to add a whole bunch of sensors and would not be practical. Also, those computers from the late '80s through the mid '90s had an extremely high failure rate, as in 99 percent. They are the single biggest reason why today yet, a lot of people think they're going to "reset" or magically fix something by disconnecting a battery cable for a few minutes. That did work sometimes with those computers, but that is not a recommended practice today, and rarely solves anything.

I've also never heard of just using a GM ignition module with a Chrysler distributor. If that would work electrically, it would be a more practical alternative to using the whole GM distributor. Right off the bat I have two questions. The first has to do with it connecting to the ignition coil. That's done under the distributor cap on GM distributors, and externally on Chryslers. The other issue is GM's modules must be mounted on a large aluminum plate with heat-sink compound in between for good heat transfer. Without that, the module will overheat in short order and short. Even in the distributor, failure to use that special grease results in numerous repeat module failures.

Let me know how you proceed. If this works, it would be something to add to my memory banks.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Monday, April 10th, 2023 AT 6:28 PM

Please login or register to post a reply.

Sponsored links