Hi,
If you are getting a remanufactured part from the same company, it could be an issue with how they are rebuilt, or the parts used in the rebuild.
Did you get the same brand from the same place?
Keep in mind, based on what it's doing, there really isn't any other cause. The starter turns indicating power is present direct from the battery to the motor, and the starter is actuated which indicates power is being sent to the S terminal on the starter solenoid. Since these are both happening, but the Bendix kicks out and the motor still spins, the problem is in the solenoid/Bendix.
Let me know if it is the brand. If it is, try a different brand and see if that makes a difference.
Also, if you could record what it is doing and upload it for me to hear, I should be able to confirm what is happening.
Let me know.
Take care,
Joe
Tuesday, May 31st, 2022 AT 7:58 PM