1999 Saturn SL Brake Thump and High Idle
Suggested Repair
Inspect under the hood for fuel leaks and disconnected vacuum lines, and confirm the coolant is full because a low level can raise idle. Check whether the check engine light is on. Have the tires inspected and rotated for possible separation, and inspect the brakes.
Conversation Summary
A 1999 Saturn SL with 111,000 miles thumps from the front driver's side during moderate or light braking, but not hard braking. It also revs to about 2500 rpm at startup, rises when the clutch is pressed, and idles high enough in first gear to pull the car. The exhaust rattles at idle and startup, and a brief fuel smell has occurred a few times. The expert advised taking any fuel smell seriously, checking for leaks and unhooked vacuum lines, verifying coolant level, noting any check engine light, and inspecting or rotating the tires; separating tires or worn brakes may cause the thump.
