Decided to take car to another tranny shop for 2nd opinion. They also found no codes, but asked them to drain and flush the tranny to see if that would help. They took off the pan and found no debris. They did find the dipstick cap in the pan, that Ford pushes into the pan on their new trannys. They also found no error codes. They said it needed to be rebuilt.
The car had started shifting normally again, so I drove it awhile. When first driven for the day, it shifted perfectly. If let sit for a couple of hours, then it would go back to the intermittently shifting into neutral again. It also started slipping a little on start out, but when I reached highway speed would work fine.
I then had a shop drain out two quarts of fluid and put in two quarts of Lucas Transmission treatment. After about 50 miles of driving it seemed like this was going to work, but then started the same thing over, meaning occasionally shifting into neutral at highway speed and occasionally slipping when first starting out. I discovered by trial and error, that if I put the gearshift in the Drive position and not overdrive, it would shift perfect all the way into 3rd gear. No slipping, no going into neutral, no nothing.
Although I know anything mechanical can fail, this tranny only has 20,000 miles on it and the type of problems it has are unlike anything I've encountered before. It's not like worn bands, etc. It almost seems like a linkage problem or possibly a valve problem but not a $1800 total rebuild problem. It also seems like the characteristics I describing should point to a specific problem that has happened many times over the years that Ford has made this tranny. Any help would be appreciated.
Rod
SPONSORED LINKS
Wednesday, January 28th, 2009 AT 11:40 PM