1998 Chevy Lumina Camshaft Failure

Avatar
ADA35
  • MEMBER
  • 1 POST
I've had a '98 Chevy Lumina (my adult car after I earned my Bachelors) for over a year. I got a very good deal for it, paying about $3500 for it, title and all. A week later, of course, I had a wreck and had to pay for minor reparis and slightly more body work. However, the car has been acting fine for about a year.

Last Friday, while driving home, the oil light came on and the car quit. One subsequent attempts to crank up, the engine would turn over but run rough and quit.

The mechanic called me today and said the camshaft had broken, and he would have to take the engine out, replace the camshaft, and replace the oil pump. I didn't know to ask if the break was clean or not. He told me a rough estimate would be about $1400 or more.

So, I have two questions. First, does the mechanic sound legit? Second, is fixing the car worth it or should I just look around for another car and sell the Lumina for however much it is worth. Money is an issue, though my husband and I can always borrow from our parents.

The car has been good for the past year, so I hate to give it up, but I would also hate to only begin the first of many expensive repairs.

Thank you,

ada35
Oct 9, 2006 at 8:59 AM
Advertisement
Avatar
BURRBRIAN
  • ✓Experienced Mechanic
  • 158 POSTS
I can't qoute you exact prices but I believe that you can get a new motor for somewhere around the money you are talking. Check out the GM Goodwrench engine site and you will find that they give a 36 month - 50,000 mile warranty on most of the engines they sell. Just something to look at if you have your heart set on keeping the car. Sounds like a lot of his price would be in the labor, allthough the parts are sometimes a little pricey.
Oct 17, 2006 at 7:43 AM

Suggested Repair

Compare the quoted camshaft and oil-pump repair with a GM Goodwrench replacement engine, which may cost a similar amount and includes a 36-month/50,000-mile warranty. Much of the estimate is likely labor.

Conversation Summary

The owner of a 1998 Chevy Lumina reported that the oil light came on, the engine quit, and it would crank but run roughly and stall. A mechanic diagnosed a broken camshaft and estimated about $1400 or more to remove the engine and replace the camshaft and oil pump. The expert could not quote exact prices but suggested comparing that repair with a GM Goodwrench replacement engine carrying a 36-month/50,000-mile warranty, noting that labor makes up much of the cost and parts can also be expensive.

Add a reply
Join 2CarPros for free, one of the most advanced car repair communities on the internet. From first-time drivers to seasoned mechanics, everyone is welcome to reply, share details, and get better answers. You can add a temporary image or video first; uploads are limited to 20 MB.

Frequently Asked Problems for This Vehicle