1991 Buick Skylark Overheating
A couple of questions.
Do you have to keep adding water?
Have you had the compression checked?
Have you had the intake Manifold inspected for cracks?
It almost sounds like you have a cracked intake of Cylinder Head. Hopefully a compression check will show where it is cracked.
Here is my take.....if it was just a overheating problem, then I would look at the coolant components. But since you have running issues also, that makes me believe you have problems in the engine. Rough running like you describe does sound like a intake manifold leak.
Not sure how mechanically inclinded you are, but to replace the intake is not that hard of a job. Probably take you around 4 hours, or longer if you havent done it before.
If this were my car, I would probebly remove the intake and cylinder head. Have them both checked for cracks and warping. Repair if possible, or replace if bad.
NOTE: before sinking time and money in this car, you might want to check the compression and see if you might have major problems. If the compression checked good, I might be tempted to just stop with the intake. But definantly stop when you find a problem. If the intake is cracked, dont pull the head unless you have low compression or obvious signs of problems with it.
I do not have to keep adding water. That seem fine. I took it today to another mechanic (whom I trust) to see if he can tell me what is the trouble. I am not mechanically "abled" at all. I am a water color artist! :-) I suppose it sounds like an obvious thing to check the manifold since I had it repaired once already, but I didn't. I'll call the mechanic tomorrow to have him do a compression check, and check the manifold if he hasn't already; and ask him to look for a cracked intake of Cylinder head, too? I'll report back on what I find out from the mechanic. Thanks so much for replying!
Suggested Repair
Have a compression test and a running vacuum-gauge check performed. Inspect the intake manifold and cylinder head for cracks or warping, and check for a dead cylinder or plugged catalytic converter. If compression is good and the intake is cracked, repair or replace the intake without removing the head unless compression is low or the head shows damage.
Conversation Summary
A 1991 Buick Skylark 2.5 began running very rough and lost heater output after a radiator repair, then overheated, backfired, lost power, and dropped to about 12 mpg despite plugs, cap, rotor, air filter, hose, and thermostat work. Coolant level stays stable. The expert suspects a cracked intake manifold or cylinder head and recommends a compression test before further teardown, stopping at the first confirmed fault. Another reply suggests a vacuum-gauge test for a dead cylinder or plugged catalytic converter.
