2000 BMW 328i Cold Whine and No-Start
Suggested Repair
A fully charged battery should still start the car with a bad alternator, so verify battery charge and the no-start/fuel concern after the used alternator install. If the whine occurs with the key on and the engine off, check for an electric AIR pump running; if it only occurs while running, remove the drive belt to separate accessory noise from engine noise. The cold whine is likely a failing deflection pulley bearing. For the intermittent coolant warning with a full system and no leaks, pressure-test the cooling system and cap and check the coolant level sensor and expansion tank.
Conversation Summary
A 2000 BMW 328i with 83,000 miles developed a loud morning whine that disappeared once warm, plus an intermittent coolant warning despite a full system and no leaks. After a shop suspected the alternator and a used unit was installed, the car cranked and powered up but would not start, as if it were not getting fuel, and the whine remained with the key on. Experts said it should still start on a charged battery, suggested distinguishing a key-on electric AIR pump from a running accessory or engine noise by belt removal, and attributed the cold noise to a failing deflection pulley bearing. They also advised pressure-testing the cooling system and cap and checking the coolant level sensor and expansion tank.
