It is possible to get a new one that does not work or that is the wrong temperature.
How hot are you letting it get? That is a 192 degree unit, If you test it in hot coolant it should start to open at 192 and fully open by 212 degrees.
It is also possible that the water flush has frozen in a small spot and the pump cannot circulate the coolant past it. Not really likely unless you took a couple hours from flushing to filling.
What was the original reason for the flush? No heat or overheating?
If you fill the system and just start the engine, does the coolant start bubbling or running over? If it does and the issue was overheating you may have a bad head gasket. Especially if it goes from cold to hot in a very short time.
Image (Click to make bigger)
Wednesday, October 28th, 2020 AT 12:36 PM
(Merged)