Keep BMW 528xi 33k or Porsche Cayenne 70k

CLAUDIO415

MEMBER
2013 BMW 528
2.0L
4 CYL
TURBO
AWD
AUTOMATIC
34,000 MILES

I own these two clean cars BMW 528 XI 2013 with 34,000 miles No warranty and Porsche Cayenne 2011 70,000 miles with two years 90,000 miles remaining on the warranty. I am having a hard time deciding which one of the cars to let go due reliability for everyday use, maintenance cost and dependability. I looking to trade in one of the cars for family SUV. Advice from mechanic and previous owner will be appreciated.

1 Reply

KEN L

MASTER CERTIFIED MECHANIC
47,526 POSTS

Hello,

Boy, that is a tough call. With those mileages the cars are about the same. Though the BMW can have vanos problems at about 65k and the Porsche is more expensive to maintain.

Hope this helps

Best, Ken