Headlights stay on even during the day when the car is set to automatic

If I turn them off manually they turn off, but if I leave it in automatic they remain on at all times. I recently upgraded my bulbs from halogen to LED. At first I thought that was the issue but that would not be the issue as the car is the one that controls when power is diverted to the headlights. My next guess was that the ambient light sensor went out. Which I already replaced and that did not fix the issue either. I don't know what else it could be.