The best oil is the one in the weight the manufacturer specifies. In your case I don't think the oil is the problem. If the rattle started after the oil change as you imply in your post, it is more likely just a defect in the filter.
I've had filters where the valve inside was bad or in some way damaged and it would cause start up rattle because it didn't hold oil in it. Changed out the filter for a different one and the rattle went away. As for filter brands, I try to stay with original equipment or if not possible I'll use Wix, Baldwin, or Mann depending on the application.
As for using a heavier oil, if you had a few hundred thousand miles on the engine and it was rattling all the time, not just on the initial start then maybe, but in 99 percent of cases the specified oil is the right one to use.
Friday, July 17th, 2020 AT 8:33 AM