Deceleration stall/warm stall restart stall

Tiny
IRISJAJ
  • MEMBER
  • 2005 CHEVROLET CLASSIC
  • 2.2L
  • 4 CYL
  • 2WD
  • AUTOMATIC
  • 136,000 MILES
Car starts, drives fine or idles fine for a few minutes. Daughter takes to school, short distance, drives fine. After school, she drives fine to sister's school, then stalls at deceleration. Starts back up. Stalls. Then will not idle enough to put into drive. I recreated in garage. Started fine, idle, no foot on gas, shuts off after five minutes (warm). Restarts, then stalls, but I hear the fuel pump seconds before it stalls. Then engine shuts down, fuel pump goes off. Has had no overheating issues. Severe oil seems to have gotten all over alternator area. I opened the air intake box to clean throttle body. Oily gold color fluid in intake box. Cleaned it out. Cleaned IACV. Replaced crumbling PVC hose (no valve in this model). Replaced valve cover gasket and spark plugs, which were caked in oil, not dripping. Have driven since these items done, and no more oil on spark plugs or in intake box. (Previous owner unknown issues) Car ran fine for eight months we have had. Got an oil change a week or two later, it starts to stall. Use code reader got P0101 and P0171. Do not want to throw parts at it, I want to fix the issue.
Thursday, May 17th, 2018 AT 11:42 PM

21 Replies

Tiny
IRISJAJ
  • MEMBER
  • 10 POSTS
Oh and no check engine light is on. No theft light issues.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Thursday, May 17th, 2018 AT 11:48 PM
Tiny
CARADIODOC
  • MECHANIC
  • 33,916 POSTS
P0101 - Mass or Volume Air Flow Circuit Low Input
P0171 - System too Lean (Bank 1)

If you go to this page:

https://www.2carpros.com/trouble_codes/obd2

You can find more information for each fault code by clicking on the code numbers highlighted in blue.

You have done a lot of work already to find the cause of this stalling. Have you checked for spark and fuel pressure when the engine will not restart? If you are losing spark, we should consider the crankshaft position sensor or camshaft position sensor. Those often fail on any engine brand by becoming heat-sensitive, then they work again after they cool down for about an hour. The clinker here is loss of one of those signals results in loss of spark and the fuel pump will stop running. The dandy clue you observed that you can still hear the pump running for a couple of seconds after the engine stalls indicates the cam and crank sensors were still working.

The biggest clue that smacked me alongside the head was the stalling when coasting. This has happened to me three times on two minivans, and twice on two older cars. The cause was always the fuel strainer on the housing the fuel pump sits in. First thing I would do is rent or borrow a fuel pressure gauge. Attach it to the fuel rail test port, then run it under the rear of the hood and clip it under a wiper arm so you can watch it while driving. The first two I ran into this on, both had carburetor engines, and it was easy to figure out they were starving for fuel. The first time this happened to my 1988 Grand Caravan, it took me four hours to get through Minneapolis with all three interstate bypasses down to two lanes for road construction. Once through the city, the engine ran fine for two hours. The clue, as I figured out later, was the stalling always occurred when the largest volume of fuel was being pumped, which is during coasting. That is why the engine ran fine when accelerating or cruising at highway speed, and stalled when slowing down for turns.

The cause all five times was a plugged pick-up screen on the supply tube in the gas tank. The additional clue is once the stalling occurs, the screen will stretch out and pass fuel again after sitting about five to ten minutes. Had I known it at the time, I suspect I could have made it through the city easier if I had unplugged the vacuum hose from the fuel pressure regulator, and plugged it. That would cause fuel pressure to go too high, with black exhaust smoke and bad fuel mileage, but with the higher return restriction, less volume of fuel would flow back into the tank, and the pump would be able to keep up with demand.

The second time this happened to my 1988 Grand Caravan, it only acted up when dragging a huge tandem-axle enclosed trailer. I had been chasing the problem for almost a year with the fuel pressure gauge attached to the radio antenna. Normal fuel pressure is around 45 to 50 psi. Some engines, GM's in particular, will not start or run with fuel pressure just a few pounds low. My engine ran fine down to 20 psi, and would start to surge and sputter at 15 psi. I found that lifting the accelerator pedal for an instant would cause the pressure to pop back up to 45 psi, then it would slowly drop again over about twenty seconds. I nursed it over fifty miles by doing that.

That screen costs $3.00 for the older cars, and around $12.00 for my Caravans. Running problems are never solved on Chrysler vehicles with gas engines by replacing the fuel filter, but that is not true on other brands. Since it is easier to replace than the in-tank screen, you might try that first if fuel pressure is the issue. The issue is plugged fuel filters act differently than plugged fuel strainers. Fuel filters are not affected one way or the other by time. The engine will be hard to start and the stalling or poor performance will be there right away. Plugged strainers take some time to show up. In my case this was always around fifteen miles, and for some reason, always on the first really hot summer days. I suspect the vacuum created by the pump pulling against the plugged strainer caused it to collapse and block the passage even more. After sitting for ten minutes, the strainer stretches out and will let gas pass again for another few minutes.

The symptoms are different, as I mentioned, with fuel injection. The more load the engine is under, the better it will run. The stalling occurs when the largest volume of fuel must be pumped, which is during coasting. To explain, when a molecule of gas is getting ready to leave the tip of the injector, there are two forces acting on it. One is intake manifold vacuum that is pulling on it, and the other is fuel pressure that is pushing on it. Fuel pressure is basically held constant by the pressure regulator, then the engine computer is programmed to pulse the injectors open a very precise amount of time calculated from manifold vacuum on Chrysler's, and the amount of air passing through the mass air flow sensor on all other brands. The issue is when you are coasting, manifold vacuum goes way up, and that would tug really hard on the gas to pull it out of the injectors. That would lead to an excessively rich mixture, loss of fuel mileage, and increased emissions. To prevent that, the fuel pressure regulators have a vacuum port that is connected to intake manifold vacuum. When vacuum goes up, it pulls on the spring-loaded valve to cause it to maintain a lower fuel pressure. As vacuum increases, fuel pressure decreases, and the net difference stays the same. The rich coast-down mixture is avoided.

Here is where the strainer becomes the problem. The fuel pump is designed to move way more fuel per minute than the engine will ever need. Of the fuel it pumps, only a tiny percentage is tapped off to go into the engine. All the rest, possibly ninety nine percent, goes through the pressure regulator and right back into the tank. The regulator presents a carefully-controlled restriction that keeps fuel pressure at specs. That restriction limits the volume of fuel the pump has to move.

When you are coasting, manifold vacuum acts on the regulator to lower fuel pressure. That means it is a lot easier for the gas to push its way through the spring-loaded valve and go back to the tank. With less restriction, the volume goes way up, and that is when the plugged strainer becomes a factor. Not enough volume can get through it, so pressure starts to drop below what the regulator is set at. The harder the pump works, the more it puts the strainer under a vacuum and forces it to collapse even more and block the pick-up tube.

I do not have an answer as to why this only occurs on really hot days, but the first time it occurred on my 1988 in Minneapolis, it acted up a little in town the next day, then not at all over the entire winter and next spring.

I just started having this problem last week, again, on the first hottest day of summer, after driving forty miles. This is on a 1994 Grand Voyager. It stalled and would not restart just as I coasted into town and my turn-off. A few hours later it started right up, and has been running fine ever since. I am prepared now with a scanner and a fuel pressure gauge for when this occurs again, but I am going to try something new to see if I can learn some clues to helping others identify this quickly. I am going to use a hose pinch-off pliers on the fuel return hose to see if that affects engine performance.

The other potential clue leading up to this is I needed to drive a truck for two weeks, and I let the van sit. Some people express a concern about mold feeding on the alcohol in today's gas, and I am wondering if that is what clogs the strainer. Most other people have just one car they drive every day, so it is constantly getting fresh, new gas dumped into the tank.

To argue against that, I have an 1980 Volare, (carburetor engine), and a 1993 Dynasty, (fuel injected), that get driven so rarely, they both have gas in the tanks that is over five years old. Have not had a problem with either one, but they both have very low miles too, so I am not sure what factors influence this failure.

I did not post a photo of the strainer for your car because the one I found from my online source is very poor and does not show anything of value. At least it is available separately from the pump housing, and the cost is similar as that for my vans.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
+2
Friday, May 18th, 2018 AT 3:33 PM
Tiny
JOHNNY G.JR
  • MECHANIC
  • 320 POSTS
That was one great explanation, well done!
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Friday, May 18th, 2018 AT 5:28 PM
Tiny
CARADIODOC
  • MECHANIC
  • 33,916 POSTS
Yeah, I got a lot of people fooled with my perceived brilliance. Now lets see if that gets the problem solved.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Friday, May 18th, 2018 AT 8:00 PM
Tiny
IRISJAJ
  • MEMBER
  • 10 POSTS
Caradiodoc, thank you for the information. I am getting access to a fuel pressure gauge and spark tester in a few days. I looked up the codes and understood lean could mean too little fuel (clogged filter, pump, screen, etc), or seems like too little fuel due to unaccounted for air entering system. Was not sure if one code is priority over the other in diagnostics, or could cause the other. So while waiting for tools, I am going to attempt to find a vacuum leak if there is one. I also learned that I should check the fuses/relays pertaining to the PCM and fuel pump just in case they look good but are not delivering proper voltage. These are simple tests I can do while waiting.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Friday, May 18th, 2018 AT 8:14 PM
Tiny
CARADIODOC
  • MECHANIC
  • 33,916 POSTS
Keep us posted on your progress.

For the diagnostic fault codes, they do not take precedence over others, exactly, but there is a condition for them to set. There is always a long list of conditions that must be met for a fault code to set, and one of those conditions is that certain other codes cannot already be set. The computer runs its tests by comparing various sensor readings and operating conditions. For example, if it sees the engine running at 2,000 rpm, it had better not see the throttle position sensor reading 0.5 volts which indicates it is at idle. The computer knows the intake air temperature sensor and the coolant temperature sensor must be reading the same temperature after the engine has been off for six hours.

There are other ways a defective sensor is detected. For my sad story about throttle position sensors, they are fed with 5.0 volts and ground, then the movable contact picks a point along the sensor that corresponds to throttle position. There are mechanical stops that limit its travel to approximately 0.5 to 4.5 volts corresponding to idle and wide-open-throttle. A broken wire, or much less commonly, a break inside the sensor, will send the signal voltage to 0.0 or 5.0 volts. Anything outside the 0.5 to 4.5 volt range is what triggers the fault codes, "TPS voltage high" or "TPS voltage to low".

Temperature sensors use the same voltage range, but the circuits are simpler. These sensors have an extremely low failure rate because there is just one component inside them. Almost all the problems with these circuits are related to cut or grounded wires and corrosion on mating connector terminals. Suppose the coolant temperature sensor has lots of corrosion on the connector terminals and reads minus forty degrees. That is a default reading that triggers the appropriate fault code. More importantly, the computer knows it cannot rely on those readings for comparing to the intake air temperature sensor. The test for the IAT sensor will be suspended. Some defects can still be detected, but some will not. Once the first defect is repaired, and in some cases not until the fault code is erased, will the tests resume. That is when a defect with the IAT will be detected and a fault code will be set. This can be very frustrating for mechanics and car owners. The mechanic prepares a repair estimate based on what he sees for fault codes. He has no way of knowing another defect has not been detected yet.

Once that first problem is solved and the rest of the tests resume, the second defect shows up and a new fault code is set. The mechanic has to tell the owner more work is needed. The customer incorrectly assumes the mechanic did not diagnose the first problem correctly or did not repair it properly. This is real common on GM vehicles with multiple anti-lock brake problems but it is important to understand it is not common to have two related problems show up at exactly the same time. This issue concerning multiple unknown fault codes has less chance of occurring when the first problem is repaired right away. Too often a customer says they ignored the warning light for many months or even years. That is when the additional problems have time to develop.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
+1
Friday, May 18th, 2018 AT 9:24 PM
Tiny
IRISJAJ
  • MEMBER
  • 10 POSTS
So, upon key on, prime pressure was about 40, but steadily lowered as it sat in on position. Pump came on and shut off as expected/normal. Then I started car. Video shows pressure while running. About 1:24 I rev engine and let go back to idle. Then shut down occurs. I did hear the fuel pump slightly before engine began to have issues and heard it approximately three seconds after shut down.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Thursday, May 24th, 2018 AT 3:05 PM
Tiny
CARADIODOC
  • MECHANIC
  • 33,916 POSTS
Check to see if you are also losing spark. If you are, the better suspects are the crankshaft position sensor and the camshaft position sensor.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
+1
Thursday, May 24th, 2018 AT 7:01 PM
Tiny
IRISJAJ
  • MEMBER
  • 10 POSTS
Okay, so did a spark test, well what I think is one. I put an inline tester on and cranked. I did not start it. Tester light up. Also did a test light on ignition module. Light was faint but there upon crank. Do I need to run the spark test while idling to see if I lose spark? That will work for about one plug as it does not run for more than three seconds after first stall.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Friday, May 25th, 2018 AT 1:59 PM
Tiny
CARADIODOC
  • MECHANIC
  • 33,916 POSTS
You need to test for what is missing when the no -start is occurring. If the engine runs, spark, fuel, compression, and proper timing of all those events has to be okay at that time.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
+1
Friday, May 25th, 2018 AT 6:58 PM
Tiny
IRISJAJ
  • MEMBER
  • 10 POSTS
Okay, so below is the pressure gauge test with priming of fuel, then start, run, shut off. And attempts to restart. Tested spark after it shut off. Had positive spark. May not be able to tell in video, but I saw light pulsing. I tested all the relays and fuses. I took relays out and tested with battery and resistance. All tested good. Note 1: The key in the ignition seemed to be quite difficult to get to turn to on/start positions. Does not always happen, but seems more so today because I wanted to film it. Note 2: The cooling fans have not seemed to ever turn on. When I was checking fuses not those specific to cooling, as most are relays, they suddenly turned on with koeo. But engine had not been running recently (within last forty minutes).
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Saturday, May 26th, 2018 AT 3:32 PM
Tiny
CARADIODOC
  • MECHANIC
  • 33,916 POSTS
I am not able to get videos to run. Can you just tell me what fuel pressures you find and what changes when the stalling occurs?
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Saturday, May 26th, 2018 AT 8:32 PM
Tiny
IRISJAJ
  • MEMBER
  • 10 POSTS
Fuel pressure when priming is at 40, but drops rapidly. We keyed on three times, same pressure and same steady drop. Crank and fuel pressure goes up and runs at approximately 50. Ran for approximately three minutes. Fuel pump sounds like it turns on, and then fuel pressure suddenly drops, engine hesitates and shuts off. Then fuel pump turns off. Can restart but shuts off after a few seconds. Fuel pressure primes to 40, shoots to around 50 when cranks, but does not hold. Repeated same. We had rpm needle movement when cranking to restart. We also had spark during restart attempts. About ten minutes later, it would run for approximately thirty seconds and shut off. Always hear fuel pump before it begins to shut off. Hear pump, then immediate engine shudder/sputter and shuts off. I am rethinking the fuel pump sock, fuel filter clog issue. Like the pump is trying to continue but works extra hard when a block somewhere happens. Causes the lean code, pump attempts to correct and cannot.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Saturday, May 26th, 2018 AT 9:11 PM
Tiny
IRISJAJ
  • MEMBER
  • 10 POSTS
Different format. Maybe it will be better. Maybe you can hear something I cannot.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Saturday, May 26th, 2018 AT 10:25 PM
Tiny
CARADIODOC
  • MECHANIC
  • 33,916 POSTS
That pickup strainer does not normally act exactly like what you described, but my experience has always been with Chrysler products. On those, you will never solve a running problem by replacing the fuel filter as they last the life of the car, but they do seem to solve quite a few problems on GM vehicles. Still, a fuel filter that is plugged is normally plugged, period. It is that strainer in the tank that I suspect collapses and blocks the pick-up tube, then the vacuum created by the pump pulls it closed even harder.

To add to the confusion, Chrysler fuel pumps almost always fail by failing to start up, leaving you sitting in the driveway. Once running, they rarely stop until you stop the engine. GM pumps are just the opposite. When they start to fail, they commonly start up and run fine for a while, then they stop a few minutes later when you are on the side of the road. Given that history, it is possible you just have a pump that is getting tired. Either way, you found the clue with the pressure tests.

There is two ways to replace the fuel pump. I always choose the cheapest way for my own stuff, then I only have me to blame if I have to do the job a second time. That is to buy the pump and motor as a unit that gets installed into your existing housing. By using the original housing over, you are reusing the fuel level float and sending unit, the plastic ports on top that the hoses connect to, and that strainer. If you buy the more expensive assembly including the housing, you get all that stuff new, plus all the electrical connections. This is the only way I would repair a customer's car to insure they do not get stranded on the side of the road.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
+1
Saturday, May 26th, 2018 AT 10:26 PM
Tiny
CARADIODOC
  • MECHANIC
  • 33,916 POSTS
Happy days are here again! I just did a search for your fuel pump and found a number of interesting tidbits. First of all, the pump and motor is very inexpensive, and, ... It comes with a replacement strainer. For my vehicles, that strainer costs about $12.00. You get that included.

Next, the complete assembly with the housing only costs a few dollars more. I looked at Rock Auto and found the complete unit is less than half as much as I expected. If you are going to go through all the work of dropping the gas tank and doing this service, avoid future aggravation and go with the complete housing/pump assembly.

The plastic nipples I mentioned previously are a common cause of leaks on Ford products, and the only way to solve that is to replace the complete housing, even when the pump is not defective. Those nipples do not cause much trouble on GM products, but with the new housing, you get those new too.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Saturday, May 26th, 2018 AT 10:32 PM
Tiny
CARADIODOC
  • MECHANIC
  • 33,916 POSTS
I cannot view any videos. That is my problem. I was using a really miserable new Windows 10 laptop, but after two years, I had enough. I am back on a very nice twelve year old Sony with Windows XP. Life in all other regards is so much better.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Saturday, May 26th, 2018 AT 10:35 PM
Tiny
IRISJAJ
  • MEMBER
  • 10 POSTS
Okay, so sorry it took me so long to get back. Life has issues sometimes. Okay, so I ended up dropping the tank, which thank god was plastic. Changed the fuel pump and fuel filter. Car seems to be running fine now. No idle or stalling issues. Now to wait and see what other issues want to come out and play. Thank you so much for your help. Was not the answer I was looking for but I accomplished it with your help.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Wednesday, August 1st, 2018 AT 8:32 PM
Tiny
CARADIODOC
  • MECHANIC
  • 33,916 POSTS
Did the strainer on the pick-up tube get replaced as part of the job?
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Thursday, August 2nd, 2018 AT 8:01 PM
Tiny
IRISJAJ
  • MEMBER
  • 10 POSTS
Yes, I bought the whole assembly which included new strainer sock. I also emptied the tank and wiped down the slight film inside the tank. No debris was in the tank.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Thursday, August 2nd, 2018 AT 8:13 PM

Please login or register to post a reply.

Sponsored links