About a week ago when driving about 65 on a hill, my car suddenly went into a flashing Neutral position with limited acceleration, which I was told was transmission limp mode. The Check Engine Light also came on, and I had codes for Shift Solenoid C and D. I then had my car checked out by a transmission shop on Thursday, and they couldn't reproduce any issues. They also told me they checked the resistance on all the shift solenoids, and they all came back within the proper parameters. It was kind of funny because they basically gave me the option of a complete transmission rebuild, or to just pick my car up free of charge as is, so I opted to just pick it up. Anyway, back in mid 2020 I got the transmission checked out by a different transmission shop, who also found no issues. They just recommended a drain and fill of the transmission fluid, which I did. Now this only replaces about half of the fluid that a full flush would. So now here I am about 25,000 miles and 2 years later, and I've been told the fluid looks dark and burned again. So, should I have a new drain and fill performed? I've been told by the recent transmission shop that it's a gamble to replace the fluid when I'm already having issues. However, someone on 2CarPros also told me "Don't let anyone tell you not to replace the fluid, that's a racket trying to get you more severe problems that you then pay them to fix". So, what's the truth here? Should I have another drain and fill done? Or should I leave the fluid alone until I need to completely rebuild the transmission? For what it's worth, the transmission is working great overall, I just had that one random incident and nothing since.
Thanks,
Adam
SPONSORED LINKS
Monday, July 18th, 2022 AT 10:04 AM