Axle replaced and slips even with new axle

2007 JAGUAR X-TYPE
142,000 MILES • 3.0L • 4WD • AUTOMATIC
Avatar
MZJASMIN78
  • MEMBER
  • 16 POSTS
Replaced axle because of clunking noise. Car drove fine otherwise and fully operational. Axle replaced and failed. Retaining ring missing when removed. New part installed and retaining ring visibly present. Axle failed again. New mechanic said ring missing when inspected. What could be causing axle failure and ring to go missing? Also, appears repair not necessary as clunking noise still present when axle was working. New mechanic says ball joint worn. Car is not operational due to axle issue. Thanks for any advice!
Jun 21, 2018 at 10:46 AM
Advertisement
Avatar
STRAILER
  • ✓ASE Certified Mechanic
  • 54,837 POSTS
  • ASE Certified Mechanic
Yes, that is strange. Can you tell me if it is the front or rear axle you are having trouble with?
Cheers, Ken
Jun 22, 2018 at 12:08 PM
Avatar
MZJASMIN78
  • MEMBER
  • 16 POSTS
It is the passenger side front axle that was replaced. I was told the old axle could not be reinstalled because the end was sheared off. Is it possible there is shards in the transfer case affecting the new axle making the retaining ring come off and making the axle slip out?
Jun 22, 2018 at 12:17 PM
Avatar
STRAILER
  • ✓ASE Certified Mechanic
  • 54,837 POSTS
  • ASE Certified Mechanic
Not really, the axle must able to move horizontally causing the axle clip and joint end to shear on come off. Has the car been in an accident?
Jun 23, 2018 at 11:48 AM
Join 2CarPros for free, one of the most advanced car repair communities on the internet. From first-time drivers to seasoned mechanics, everyone is welcome to reply, share details, and get better answers. You can add a temporary image or video first; uploads are limited to 20 MB.
Ask a Free Question
Repair Safety Notice: This information is for general instructional purposes only. Vehicle repair can be dangerous. Verify all information, follow manufacturer service procedures, use proper tools and safety equipment, and consult a qualified repair shop when needed.