Code P0420 keeps coming back?

Tiny
CHRIS ALICIA NEWKIRK
  • MEMBER
  • 2011 INFINITI QX56
  • 5.6L
  • V8
  • 4WD
  • AUTOMATIC
  • 135,000 MILES
My vehicle listed above has had a ton of issues. The biggest was replacement of the timing chain, now it burns a little oil. The dealer says I need a new engine, but the shop who replaced the timing chain said it was fine, just needed a new timing chain.

I also have a catalytic converter light that comes on (CEL P0420) but I don't notice a performance issue. A couple years ago, the truck went into limp mode, and I had to get it towed. My mechanic couldn't figure out the issue, so he just cleared the codes, and it ran fine. I since bought a code reader so I could do the same if I needed.

A year after that, I replaced the timing chain due to a ticking sound in my engine. Immediately after that was replaced, my CEL P0420 code popped up. I've left that light on since then and it's running fine.

A couple nights ago, it started sputtering a bit. Then I got home, went back out a half hour later, and it would turn but wouldn't start. It was basically in limp mode again. I checked the codes (don't remember all, there were 4, one was P0420, and another was misfire) and should've written them down but was in a hurry. So, I just cleared them, and it runs great again.

Should I be seriously concerned here? Or should I just always keep the code reader under my seat and keep clearing the codes every 12-24 months? (Or more often?)
Friday, February 17th, 2023 AT 8:07 AM

3 Replies

Tiny
AL514
  • MECHANIC
  • 4,632 POSTS
Hello, you could be getting that code for a couple of reasons, the engine computer (ECM) monitors the front oxygen sensor and the rear one (after the Catalytic converter) and compares the frequency or switching time of each. When the sensors start to display a signal that is close to each other it will set that code. The rear oxygen sensor should have more of a steady reading because a converter actually stores oxygen and uses it to help burn off extra emissions. I'll post some other possibilities that can cause the code, but if the vehicle is going into limp mode, it is doing that to protect the converter from damage. So misfiring cylinders is what will cause a converter to melt down and fail, eventually it will melt and block off the exhaust and the vehicle won't start at all. If you're getting any misfire codes, you need to get them fixed. Converters are very expensive. But next time you get a check engine light make sure to write down all the codes, If your scan tool can look at live data, look at the rear oxygen sensor data. It should have a steady voltage signal. It's only a 0 to 1 volt switch, but it shouldn't be swing up and down.
If the main issue isn't fixed it will only get worse and leave you stranded eventually. I'll post some more info on that code.
And just one other thing, since this is a V8, the p0420 is only a Bank 1 code, so it's one side of the engine causing this code, the Bank 2 would be a P0430. So, you might have cylinders misfiring on just the Bank 1 side.

On a side note, I did find 3 Recalls, the first 2 are for the Fuel Rail pressure sensor not being torqued to spec, but the 3rd is a Recall of the sensor itself, this is something you'll want to see if it's been done or not, You don't want any fuel leaking out of the fuel rail. That could be a fire hazard besides a performance issue.

https://www.2carpros.com/articles/bad-catalytic-converter-symptoms
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
+1
Friday, February 17th, 2023 AT 9:43 AM
Tiny
CHRIS ALICIA NEWKIRK
  • MEMBER
  • 2 POSTS
Thanks for your help. Why would it perform better once I clear the codes? Also, my mechanic said the truck will likely struggle to accelerate at higher speeds if there's a cat issue, and I haven't noticed anything, which leads me to suspect that it's just an O2 sensor. He said it's likely not worth worrying about until it affects performance. So far it hasn't, although I'm wondering if having the check engine light on for so long has caused a change in fuel trim levels and eventually a limp mode issue. Your thoughts on that?
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Friday, February 17th, 2023 AT 10:06 AM
Tiny
AL514
  • MECHANIC
  • 4,632 POSTS
The converter needs to be able to store oxygen to do its job, your mechanic is referring to when the converter gets to the point of no return, when it melts down and breaks apart it will clog up the exhaust and that entire bank that the converter is on will not be able to allow its exhaust gases out, when it can't allow anything out, it can't take anything in either. So, air flow is restricted, cylinders start to foul out, all kinds of bad things happen. When you're clearing your codes out, it's clearing the memory. Modern vehicles will sometimes disable fuel injectors when there is a cylinder misfire code, or any other code that has converter damaging effects. The ECM will do what it has to when trying to save the converter from damage. And yes, it will affect fuel trim numbers, when the rear oxygen sensor starts to become active and its frequency/switching time is reaching what the front one is doing, the ECM will reduce fuel and the long term and short-term fuel trims will start to go negative, meaning taking fuel away, again to prevent converter meltdown. The mechanic doesn't care, because then he gets to sell you a $1,000.00 converter, or whatever the price it is for your vehicle. I can't imagine they are cheap for an Infinity.
But monitor the rear oxygen sensors and see what they are doing and write down any misfire codes or any other codes you get next. You also want your fuel trim numbers to be less than 10percent negative or positive. Over 10 is no good. That's too much compensation.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
+1
Friday, February 17th, 2023 AT 10:22 AM

Please login or register to post a reply.

Sponsored links