We work with all kinds of car owners from professional mechanics with many years of experience all the way down to those who can barely put in gas on their own. Often they just need reassurance and their hand held, or they need to know when and how to find a specialist.
I agree with your assessment of how some people communicate. I was way at the top, . . . of the bottom third of my high school graduating class, but I did pay attention in class, and I can put together a coherent sentence. You gotta remember for a lot of people we help, English is their second language, so allowances must be made. English was the second language for my stepfather who came here from Poland after WWII, and he became the chief editor of a newspaper. He could still be hard to understand at times, but you have to give him credit for putting in the work to live here in the U.S.
As a side note, when you take an Automotive course at a community college, it includes at least one Communications class. We get paid, and customers get charged, for what we write on the back of the repair orders. It's in the mechanic's best interest to be accurate and clear, otherwise some of what he does, he does for free.
One of my pet peeves is when people are too lazy to list all the related symptoms or clues they've observed, or they can't be bothered to list the engine size, then they get angry if we don't come up with the right solution right away. Most people are understanding and will try to work with us. Even then, it's very common for us to spend a couple of hours formatting drawings and diagrams for uploading, and typing long, detailed replies, then we never hear back. We don't know if we did any good or what the final solution was.
I didn't answer your previous question because there were too many ways to do that, and none would always apply. My best comment is the engineers can't design a car to do what they did for almost a hundred years without adding on a complicated, unnecessary, unreliable computer. We've had power locks, power windows, cruise control, air conditioning, horns, and interior lights since almost forever, but starting around the early 1990s, none of those systems work unless there's a computer involved. Chrysler had a delayed ignition key light that had a time delay back in the 1960s. It used an indestructible, inexpensive thermal timer switch that never failed. Today we must have interior lights that fade out gradually. That requires a computer. We had power door locks in the '60s that worked off a switch on the door. Today owners demand doors that lock automatically at a certain road speed or when you shift out of "park". That requires a computer. Driver's can't be bothered to push the "lock" button on their own. They also can't be expected to turn on their head lights in gloomy or rainy weather. We must have daytime running lights that run the high beams at 80 percent of normal brightness so they blind you in your rear-view mirror. That 80 percent involves "pulse-width dimming" which requires a computer. The same thing could have been done by turning on the low beams with a ten-dollar relay tied to the ignition switch. All of these computers live in a dusty, humid environment where there's huge temperature swings and lots of vibration. Those things are the deadly enemies of electronics, so by all means, lets see how much more of it we can hang on our cars.
All of these "features" require a Body Computer which adds greatly to the cost and complexity, and makes diagnosis take longer and repairs more expensive.
Computers on cars today are a fact of life that we have to live with, but now the manufacturers have figured out all kinds of ways to make them cost owners a real lot more money for repairs. I would not want to go back to the days before Engine Computers since they clean up the exhaust, but they do cause almost as much trouble as they prevent. I wouldn't have any complaint at all if we could just go to a salvage yard, buy a used computer, and throw it into a different vehicle. Some of this new programming they came up with was supposed to address the problem of car theft, but it's mostly costing legitimate owners, and cars are still being stolen.
Sorry for getting off track. Your Body Computer controls a lot of functions, and they vary depending on the optional equipment your car has. Ford can call them their "Generic Electronic Module, (GEM). On some Dodge trucks it was called their "Central Timer Module". "Body Controller" is another name you will see.
The sensors you asked about gets even more involved, and confusing. The Engine Computer needs to know road speed so it can initiate some emissions tests at higher speeds where the driver won't notice subtle changes in engine performance. The Transmission Computer needs to know road speed to calculate shifts points. The Body Computer wants to know road speed to know when to lock the doors. The Air Bag Computer needs to know road speed so it doesn't deploy the air bags at low speeds where they aren't necessary or effective. Can't forget the instrument cluster that can't run the speedometer without knowing road speed. That's just five of the computers that would each need a vehicle speed sensor, (VSS).
The Engine Computer obviously needs a coolant temperature sensor to know when to advance ignition timing, when to turn on the radiator fan, and when to add in the oxygen sensor readings to the fuel metering calculations. The Transmission Computer modifies shift schedules based on engine temperature, so it wants to know coolant temperature. If you have a temperature gauge on the instrument cluster, it needs to know coolant temperature. Even your Climate Control Computer makes vent adjustments based on coolant temperature. That's four computers that need to know the same thing, but there aren't four coolant temperature sensors on the engine.
Instead, there's just one sensor for most common circuits, then its information is shared between modules. That is done with a pair of wires called the "data buss". Today there's typically one coolant temperature sensor on the engine. It is connected to the Engine Computer. The transmission could have a fluid temperature sensor on it. It also usually has the vehicle speed sensor somewhere on its tail housing. Intake air temperature sensor is usually somewhere on the fresh air tube leading to the throttle body. It could instead be on the throttle body itself, built into the mass air flow sensor on all brands except older Chryslers, or it could be inside the Engine Computer where fresh air flows through, and may be called the "battery temperature sensor". That was an older Chrysler thing. A number of computers make adjustments based on incoming air temperature, or "ambient air temperature", but there's usually just one of those on the car.
The point I'm getting to is you can't ask how many sensors there are for any one computer, even when you count how many are bolted to the engine, the transmission, or are somewhere else. The only time you need to know which computer a sensor is wired to is when you're diagnosing that circuit. The easiest way to follow this is to look at just the Engine Computer. Suppose a dozen sensors are connected to it. Besides their signal voltages, that computer also knows engine speed, engine load, injector pulse width, (length of time they're pulsed open), throttle position, throttle direction of change, throttle rate of change, when it's at idle, and when it's at wide-open-throttle. It even knows when there's unburned oxygen in the exhaust. All of that data is compiled into a packet of digital information that is transmitted onto the data buss hundreds of times per second. Those two data buss wires are spliced and connected to every other computer module on the car. There can easily be over four dozen of them. They all receive that packet of information, then each computer can pick off what it needs to look at, and it will disregard the rest.
Once the Engine Computer is done sending its data, a different computer gets a turn at doing the same thing. The Transmission Computer, for example, will broadcast which gear it has put the transmission in, what its fluid temperature is, even how much wear has taken place in each of its clutch packs. Now every computer gets to see that information and use just the parts of it that's needed. The Overhead Compass Module, for example, doesn't care about clutch wear, so it disregards that data. Once the Transmission Computer is done sending its packet of information, the next computer does the same thing. In this way, every computer has the opportunity to know what every sensor is reporting, and how every system is operating, regardless if it needs to know that or not. This sharing of information is repeated hundreds of times per second. It is why every computer doesn't have to have its own dedicated sensor. Every sensor's readings get sent to every computer.
The best example of this is the instrument cluster. Many years ago they would have their own coolant temperature sensor, fuel level sensor, oil pressure sensor, and sometimes one or two others wired directed to it. Today there are no sensors wired to the clusters. They get all their data over the data buss.
To add to the misery, for the last dozen or so years, there can be two or three separate data busses on a car. There started being too much information and too many computers for one buss to handle. You may see a reference to a "Buss A", "Buss B", and "Buss C" in one service manual. Liken that to three entirely independent conversations taking place in a tavern. Some of the people might shift around and interact with people from a different conversation to share information, but then they go back to their original group.
Sometimes you'll see a reference to a "low-speed data buss" or a "high-speed data buss". The high-speed buss is just like with home computers where you pay more to get higher speeds, but you'd only do that when necessary. Air Bag Computers are the best example of one that uses the high-speed buss. It has to receive crash sensor data, and send out bag firing voltages instantly. To be most effective, decisions and actions must take place within a few microseconds. Engine Computers typically have two data busses they use. Circuits that involve emissions require immediate updating. Those actions related to turning on a fan relay or emissions solenoid can use the slower buss where a delay of a fraction of a second is meaningless. Same with the overhead compass or instrument cluster. Those can update through the slowest data buss there is, and it will still be hundreds of times faster than our brains can perceive.
All of this has nothing to do with oil changes. There is no sensor involved in when to change the oil. Some vehicles today do have some kind of dash indication of when the oil should be changed, but that is done through software in one of the computers. My truck has a digital gauge to show how much life is left in the oil, but that is calculated by looking at the amount of short-trip driving, long-trip driving, average engine temperature, average intake air temperature, and things like that. It even looks at the on-dash trailer brake setting when it sees a trailer is connected.
There's also no correlation between a failed sensor and the engine locking up. Seized engines are rare. Failed sensors occur all the time. This would be like saying the likelihood of having a flat tire is based on the position of your power seat. People come up with all kinds of ways to figure out when to have the oil changed. Every three months is too often if the vehicle is only driven one day a week, but it's not often enough if it's driven just a few miles at time, multiple times per day. We've always been taught almost all engine wear takes place in the few minutes when the engine warming up. That's when parts haven't yet expanded to fit properly, mainly pistons. Very little wear takes place once the engine has reached its operating temperature. That's why semi trucks can reach well over a million miles with no major repair work. They're always warmed up.
The thing to look at is what the oil has to do. Its job is to "isolate moving parts from each other". That refers to bearings and journals, and other parts that would come in contact with each other. Beyond that, it's the additives that are important and that wear out. One we've all heard about is detergents. That scrubs off carbon and other deposits. Another is "dispersants". That additive helps to keep the deposits in suspension so the oil can carry them away to the filter. Without dispersants, the bad stuff would settle at the bottom of the oil pan where eventually it could form sludge and block the oil pick-up and starve the engine of oil.
Corrosion inhibitors neutralize the acids that form from combustion gas blowby past the piston rings. Most of that blowby gets pulled out by the PCV system to be burned, but there's always a little that gets in the oil. Seal conditioners are mostly to keep the front and rear crankshaft seals soft and pliable.
Everyone you talk with will have their own story about a favorite oil brand and when the oil should be changed. I have two comments in that regard. First, it is common to hear someone's engine developed a severe oil leak right after changing brands or when switching to synthetic oil. It's not the oil, but the additives that might be responsible for that. When you drain five quarts of oil out during a normal oil change, there's still about two quarts stuck in the passages and oil pump that don't drain out. That may still have some additives in it. A different brand of oil might have just as good additives, but they are not compatible with those in the old oil. A perfect example of that is a detergent in the new oil that attacks or degrades the seal conditioner in the old oil, then the seals start to leak. Sometimes that leak will clear up over time if you stick with that new brand of oil. Sometimes the leak will slow down, but never totally clear up even when switching back to the old brand. The same is true when switching between regular and synthetic oil. Best advice here is to stick with one brand you like.
For my last comment of value related to oil, every container will have two designations to indicate whether it's compatible for your engine. For the most part this is a factor of the age of your vehicle. You'll see something to the effect of "SG / CH" on the label. Car manufacturers are constantly improving metal alloys and technology in their engines. Part of that improvement requires the oil to meet a very specific set of conditions to provide the needed protection. When a major advancement is made, they will specify what is required of the oil, then the oil producers have to change their formulations to meet those requirements. A good way to look at this is to say with each oil update, it gets "better". If the old formulation was okay for your engine, the new formulation will work just fine. It's the other way you can't go. If you buy a new car today, containers of oil you had stockpiled in your garage for many years will not meet the new car's requirements. It doesn't mean the engine will fail. It means you won't be getting all the protection you could have. That might shorten the engine's life a little. Of bigger concern now is variable valve timing. That's a new technology that greatly increases fuel mileage and horsepower, but it puts more responsibility on the oil. These systems have valving that will be adversely affected by using the wrong oil.
To get back to those classifications, in my "SG / CH" example, the "S" stands for "spark-fired engines", meaning gas engines. The "C" stands for "compression-fired engines", meaning diesels. Every time the oil's formulation goes through a significant improvement or change, the second letter increases by one, so an oil listed as "SG" is the next evolution after the old formulation that was listed as "SF". The next time there's a major advancement, which could be a few years down the road, it will be listed as "SH". I don't even know what they're up to now. We don't have to concern ourselves with that. Any oil you can buy anywhere will be of the newest classification. Once they develop the newest formula, they stop producing the older one. And remember, the newer formulas are always more than good enough for older engines. That's an age thing, not a mileage thing. There are special oils available for very high-mileage engines, regardless of how old they are. I've had a few Dodge Caravans with well over 400,000 miles, and I only used the least expensive store brand oil I could find. It may be true you get what you pay for, but in my case, that store brand oil was produced by a well-known company and was more than good enough for my needs.
Basically what I'm saying is three-month oil change intervals probably shouldn't be what you plan. Instead, look at the type of driving you do, how many miles you've driven since the last oil change, and how many of those miles were with the engine warmed up. Also consider if you drive on a lot of dusty roads and how often the engine has to pull a heavy load, whether that's a trailer, a carload of people, or it goes up and down a lot of mountains. We used to recommend an oil change every 3,000 miles, but today with the much better additives, it's not uncommon for a manufacturer to specify as much as every 10,000 miles for their vehicles. In the 1960s and '70s, 3,000 miles could mean a year for a lot of people. Today many of us put on that many miles in a month. If you do this type of calculations, it still might turn out to be an oil change roughly every three months, which is fine.
Be aware, some manufacturers, Ford in particular, used to specify a really high oil change interval to make their cost of regular maintenance appear to be much lower than that of their competitors, but when you checked the owner's manual, it showed that was for "normal", or "light" service. We used to joke about it. When you read further, there were so many conditions and limitations that it was impossible to meet the "normal" driving. No matter how you drove or how far, it always came down to using the "severe" schedule, which was identical to those of every other manufacturer, but that's not what they advertised.
Check out these articles too when you have time:
https://www.2carpros.com/articles
There's also well over 700 videos on YouTube that show how to do a lot of common repairs and services.
SPONSORED LINKS
Saturday, January 21st, 2023 AT 2:59 PM