Have the same problem with a 2004 Chevrolet Suburban. Started after mechanic replaced shift cable. Replaced starter, and ignition/start switch. Same problem. New transmission installed (unrelated) and new torque converter. With tranny install, new flywheel and the mechanic is asking for another starter (third in 12 months) and shim plate. Does not make sense to me because loud mechanical clatter like metal plate in fan blades goes away in D, 1, 2, 3 (all conditions where neutral safety switch is engaged). I can't imagine the solenoid is bad on 2 starters in a row. I'm thinking of a bad relay or welded wire. Is it more likely that it really was a bad flywheel runing starters? I'll let everyone know what we figure out.
Wednesday, February 2nd, 2022 AT 9:43 PM