Engine replacement for M/T

Tiny
BILL MARSHALL
  • MEMBER
  • 2011 INFINITI G37
  • 3.7L
  • V6
  • 2WD
  • MANUAL
  • 72,000 MILES
After a head gasket failure, which caused a radiator failure, I was told the engine had gotten too hot and a rebuild would not suffice, complete engine replacement was suggested. I have a 2011 G37S Coupe 6MT, will an engine (used) from an A/T car be compatible or do I need to source an engine from another M/T car? Finding a donor M/T car is proving extremely difficult but A/T donors are in abundance. Thanks
Thursday, August 19th, 2021 AT 6:28 PM

7 Replies

Tiny
JACOBANDNICKOLAS
  • MECHANIC
  • 109,885 POSTS
Hi,

As long as the engine is from the same year, make, and model, it should work with your manual transmission. The biggest concern is that the transmission bell housing has the same bolt pattern. If it's the same engine, it should be the same.

As far as your engine in the vehicle, how was it determine that overheating caused the need for a new engine?

Could you explain what happened and what they are telling you?

Also. If you look at pic 1 below, I highlighted numbers 18 and 20 coming off the same engine. Number 18 is a flex plate for an automatic transmission and number 20 is a flywheel for a manual transmission. Therefore, the engine is the same regardless of the transmission type. You will just need to switch a few of the parts to make it compatible with your vehicle.

Interestingly, I reviewed the directions for the removal of the engine. The only way it's listed is with an AT. I added the directions in the event you wanted to do it yourself.

Let me know if this helps or if you have other questions.

Take care,

Joe
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Thursday, August 19th, 2021 AT 8:04 PM
Tiny
BILL MARSHALL
  • MEMBER
  • 28 POSTS
Thank you for the reply, Joe. I have the full factory service manual pdf download which has the AT and MT removal and install but it doesn't specify to use "xyz" when replacing the engine for an AT or MT car. So, here's the story. I purchased the car from a private seller who said he was a 20+ year shop owner, now retired, who flips a car here and there for extra cash. Test drive went well, I loved the car, specifically sought out the MT. I pointed out a previous front end repair, which he said was a minor fb, new bumper cover and pass side HL. $9,000.00 cash and I was the new owner. Car ran great. For about 5 weeks. Coming home from work one night, I heard what I thought was a bearing whine, noticed the temp start to climb quickly and then smelled coolant. It completely lost mechanical power, electronics still worked, and coasted to a stop on the freeway. Crank, no start. Got it home, hookup up the scan tool, random misfire, cylinder 6 misfire, temperature peaked at 273.2°, hole in bottom of radiator and compression coming out of the radiator when cranked. Had it towed to a shop, who gave me the diag. I did an in-depth dig (hindsight, should have done that before the purchase), found out it was in a total loss front end accident in Maryland at 25,000 miles, auctioned off by the insurance company to a private party, 9 months later a new title was issued in AZ (my state), 3 weeks later another new title was issued (this somehow washed the title of the total loss branding, the title I have shows it's a clean and clear title).
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Thursday, August 19th, 2021 AT 10:51 PM
Tiny
JACOBANDNICKOLAS
  • MECHANIC
  • 109,885 POSTS
Hi,

As far as the switch from AT to MT, it's not a big deal. You will just switch the flex plate for the flywheel. I wonder if the bearing whine you heard was the water pump. That's a possibility.

As far as the title, wow. It seems someone knew what they were doing. If he has a dealer license, I would call him on fraud.

I asked you about what happened because I was curious about how they determined it was a total loss. It does sound like that is a good possibility, but if the coolant never made its way into the engine (oil), you may be able to have the head shaved if the block didn't warp. It's just a thought.

If you have a chance, let me know how things turn out for you. Also, if you run into trouble, let me know. I'll try my best to help from here.

Take care,

Joe
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Friday, August 20th, 2021 AT 7:22 PM
Tiny
BILL MARSHALL
  • MEMBER
  • 28 POSTS
Based on my findings, the engine was used by Nissan in multiple chassis and models/trims. The only ones that varied, slightly, were in the X (AWD) and the Nismo (performance) options, so I believe you are correct in only needing to swap the flex plate for the flywheel. Speaking of the X (AWD), I just noticed the instructions you added in your first reply are for a G37X, those only came with an AT, probably why you didn't see removal instructions for a MT.

How difficult would it be to determine if the engine did get hot enough to replace instead of repair? Would you have to disassemble it to know? For context; my uncle works at a specialty paint and supply store, majority of his customers are local shop owners / workers, one of which he always takes his vehicle to if needing repairs. This is where I took my car per his suggestion. The shop is owned and ran by 2 very nice older gentlemen (both 60 - 70), with 1 other employee. When I dropped the car off and explained everything, the owner said he would look at the car in the next few days to assess the damages and see if he / they even wanted to take on such a large job, depending on what was needed. I say this with a grain of salt, but after talking to the owner again today, I honestly don't think he even looked at the car and based his diag on my info alone. The car is still in the same spot the tow truck dropped it in weeks ago, I asked if he tried to start it at all (it's keyless / push button but it's a bit tricky when the fob is dead, plus I had disconnected the battery after it stopped running since it was brand new), he said he never tried. Which, to me, means he didn't even try to pull codes or freeze frame data. He also mentioned that steel sleeves start to shift when aluminum gets that hot, which requires boring and new sleeves. I assumed he scoped a few of the cylinders or something but having looked it up, that engine doesn't have factory sleeved cylinders, it's a standard aluminum open deck block.

What would be needed to determine if the engine is a lost cause?
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Sunday, August 22nd, 2021 AT 10:28 PM
Tiny
JACOBANDNICKOLAS
  • MECHANIC
  • 109,885 POSTS
Hi,

What I would suggest is to perform a compression test to see if there is a head gasket issue. Oftentimes, you will find two cylinders side by side that are low in compression.

If you find that one or more cylinders do have low compression, then I would recommend removing the cylinder head and inspecting the cylinder head and engine block to see if it warped.

Here is a link that explains how to perform a compression test. You will need a compression gauge, but if you don't have one, most parts stores will lend one to you.

https://www.2carpros.com/articles/how-to-test-engine-compression

If I had your vehicle, that is where I would start. Also, if you do this, before you remove the spark plugs, record the engine cranking and upload it for me to hear. I should be able to tell what you can expect.

Here is another link you may find of interest. It explains how to test for a blown head gasket and does discuss the neighboring cylinders concerns. I'm just adding this in the event you want to review it.

https://www.2carpros.com/articles/head-gasket-blown-test

I can help you through the entire process, so let me know what direction you want to go or what I can do to help. If the heads need removed, it is a larger job, but if you have the desire to do it, I'll be happy to help.

Take care,

Joe

Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Monday, August 23rd, 2021 AT 6:03 PM
Tiny
BILL MARSHALL
  • MEMBER
  • 28 POSTS
Thank you. I'm glad to hear that. I do have a background in the field, though, unused for a while. I attended AAI (Arizona Automotive Institute) right out of high school and graduate in the top 5% of my class followed by 3+ years at a Chevrolet Dealership, starting as a lube tech and moved on to drivability, before leaving the field altogether. I used to be obsessed with Hondas, having owned at least a dozen of them. I've definitely pulled, turn down and rebuilt my fair share of engines, but never anything bigger than a 4 cylinder. As that may all sound like I probably don't need to be here asking you questions, all of that was 15+ years ago. I haven't done much more than a brake job or replacing engine mounts for friends and family in a decade. I'm sure, once this ball gets rolling, I'll have a few questions. Thanks
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Monday, August 23rd, 2021 AT 6:54 PM
Tiny
JACOBANDNICKOLAS
  • MECHANIC
  • 109,885 POSTS
It sounds like you will be fine fixing this yourself. Let me know if you need anything or if I can help in any way. You are always welcome here.

Take care,

Joe
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Monday, August 23rd, 2021 AT 7:20 PM

Please login or register to post a reply.

Related Engine Replace/Remove Content

Sponsored links