Broken teeth on pinion gears in rear differential?

Tiny
BILL MARSHALL
  • MEMBER
  • 2004 CHEVROLET TAHOE
  • 5.3L
  • V8
  • 4WD
  • AUTOMATIC
  • 154,000 MILES
I just bought this vehicle 2 weeks ago. It's an LT and it was kept in great condition. While doing an oil change, I noticed the rear diff cover was seeping, so I decided to replace the cover gasket. When I removed the cover, I discovered that many of the teeth on the pinion gears are chipped or broken. The truck drives fine, very smooth in fact and it doesn't make any whining, grinding or popping sounds that you would normally associate with this kind of issue. I made some calls and got a few quotes to replace the pinion gears, parts and labor $700-$1,000. I was initially looking at PPV Tahoe's and the number one failure item on them (according to reviews) is the rear diffs. Understandable, considering the intended use of the vehicle. Are these damaged pinion gears a sign that my Tahoe has suffered extended use and abuse or is this a "it happens to every vehicle, eventually" situation? Would it be beneficial to buy a full rear axle assembly from a salvage yard and just swap the whole thing? I can get one of those for around $250 but most have about the same mileage as my damaged one. Also, how can I tell if I have active brake control, it's asked when searching for a full rear end. Thanks.
Saturday, November 4th, 2023 AT 11:51 AM

5 Replies

Tiny
JACOBANDNICKOLAS
  • MECHANIC
  • 109,700 POSTS
Hi,

The damage could be from abuse, but chances are, it isn't. There is a history of this happening.

Based on the mileage, I would get one from a salvage yard. Try to find one with the lowest mileage possible. Before installing it, remove the cover and do a thorough inspection.

Keep in mind, you have to get one with the same gear ratio. It has to be the same as the front's ratio.

I attached directions below. They are somewhat vague but will help get you through the procedure.

Let me know if this helps.

Take care,

joe

See pics below.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
+1
Saturday, November 4th, 2023 AT 10:13 PM
Tiny
CARADIODOC
  • MECHANIC
  • 33,870 POSTS
I've never seen this before on any model, so if your research says this is common on this model, I would suggest it is a result of GM's habit of coming up with new designs and putting them into production for owners to test and find failures. It has been almost 20 years, so if this is a design issue, problems should have occurred a long time ago, (and we would have heard more about it).

Those four small gears actually see very little use so they rarely wear out. They are planted inside the carrier housing and basically sit still while that entire unit rotates as an assembly. That's why they do not make noise. The only time those gears move is when you go around any type of corner, or when one tire is slightly smaller than the other one. The two wheels have to be rotating at different speeds. The biggest stress they will encounter is when one wheel is spinning when that tire is on ice or mud, then that tire suddenly gets traction and makes the other wheel want to spin.

That is also the time you will hear rumbling from those gears. To observe that, raise the rear tires off the ground and support the truck on jack stands. Run the engine, in gear, and most of the time both rear wheels will spin together, at the same speed. Now hit the brakes, then block one wheel with something like a 2 x 4 or cement block. Be careful if you use a long 2 x 4 with the tire still spinning as it can catch the board and shout it out unexpectedly. I hold it up at a high angle and press it against the tire until it stops spinning, then I push the board under the tire to hold it from starting up again.

Now, if this is an "open" differential, with the rear driveshaft spinning at the same speed as before, the blocked tire will be standing still and the other one will be spinning twice as fast as before. Now is when those axle and spider gears are running the fastest they ever will, and this is when you'll hear any noise they might cause. I suspect you're going to hear a lot of crunching or growling.

If this was due to abuse, another place to look is where the pinion shaft goes through the housing. In your dandy photo, I highlighted it with a blue box, and my red arrow is pointing to it. Rotate the driveshaft roughly half a revolution and this window will move away, then you'll see the hole where the shaft goes through. It's roughly one inch in diameter. On highly abused differentials, especially those on older muscle cars with manual transmissions, that hole gets hammered out into a big oval. That lets the shaft walk back and forth. You won't usually notice anything while driving, but if you put it in "park" on an incline, or in gear if it's a manual transmission, the vehicle is able to coast a good four to eight inches before stopping. That's due to that shaft being able to move around while the driveshaft is held in place. There's no fix for that other than to replace the center section. There's also a small bolt with a 5/16" head holding that shaft in place. To be able to walk back and forth in the oval-shaped holes, that pin has to be sheared off. It's only a matter of time before the shaft slides out and catches on the housing. That can result in an exploded housing or a broken transmission housing.

If those two holes are okay, repairs are likely going to be rather straight forward and somewhat easy for a competent do-it-yourselfer. It's the larger ring gear and the pinion gear driven by the driveshaft that are extremely critical. There are some serious adjustments that move those gears in various directions to prevent noise and promote proper wear patterns. Best is to leave that alone as we never set them up as well as how they came from the manufacturer of the assembly. Those four smaller gears are a different story. As I mentioned, they only rotate when the two wheels are turning at different speeds, and they turn way too slowly to make noise. There are no spacing adjustments because it isn't necessary.

Remove that small bolt with the 5/16" head. Use a small 1/4" ratchet or a small box wrench, and don't use a lot of force. You can create more misery if that bolt snaps off. The only threads on it are right under the head, for less than a half inch, then the rest is just a straight, smooth pin, about 1/4" in diameter. If excessive hammering has led to the 1" pin moving a little, that will deform the smaller bolt and start to shear it off. It also makes it want to not turn freely. If you encounter that, work it back and forth while slowly turning it out a little more each time.

Once that pin is removed, rotate the driveshaft until that 1" pin can be pushed out. Finger pressure should do it. Often they slide out from gravity and unexpectedly land on our feet. With that shaft out, grab either rear tire and rotate it by hand. As you do that, the top and bottom spider gears will walk toward or away from the opening. When they go far enough, you can lift the top one off and pull the bottom one out. You'll have to turn the tire both ways. One way brings the top gear toward you, then spinning the tire the other way walks the bottom gear toward you. If those are the only two you're going to replace, that is as far as you need to go. Note there's a stamped steel plate on the back of each gear. They form a wear surface and should be reinstalled with the replacement gears. Installing them can get a little tedious because you have to start each one at the same time so as you rotate the tire again, they'll be drawn in and reach the holes in the housing at the same time. If you accomplish that on the first try, you're much better than the rest of us. A better bet is you're going to be off by a couple of teeth the first time, and it will take a half dozen attempts before they're both in position at the same time so the shaft can be slid back in.

If you need to replace the two axle gears too, that is done as soon as those two spider gears are walked out. Rotate the driveshaft again to put the carrier in the same orientation as it is in your photo. With the pinion shaft out, grab one rear tire / wheel and push it in toward the truck. It will go about a quarter inch. Back in the differential, you'll see the axle shaft has moved through its gear, and a large C-clip is exposed. It had been sitting in a pocket in the middle of the gear. Sometimes we get lucky and it falls off from gravity. When gravity isn't strong enough, you'll need to spin it around and sometimes fight with it to get it to slide off. If you don't see that C-clip, it's possible the gear stuck to the axle shaft and moved in with it. Just push the gear back with your finger, then you'll see that C-clip.

If you have to, you can pull the wheel / tire / axle shaft out a little to make room to slide the axle gear off the axle shaft. I should mention too, this works when you have rear drum brakes. A lot of trucks today have rear disc brakes. Typically we aren't strong enough to push the wheel and tire in to remove the C-clip because the caliper slides too hard. In that case, you'll have to take extra time to remove the wheel / tire, and then the caliper, so the brake rotor and axle shaft can be pushed in. Slide the replacement gear onto the axle shaft, then slide the C-clip back on It will likely spin around and fall off at least three times. Swear words usually don't help. Once that C-clip is on the shaft, if the wheel has been removed, you can push the shaft out with your finger from inside the differential housing. Doing so locks the C-clip in place so it can't fall out.

Do the same thing on the other side. As a side note, these are the same steps we take when replacing a leaking grease seal on the ends of the axle housing. If you want to pursue that, you need to slide the axle shaft out. That can be a messy job, so be prepared with rags and perhaps some cardboard on the floor to catch the few drops of gear lube.

From this point, continue with installing the two spider gears. Once the pinion shaft is back in place, all four gears are held in place. If I had a choice, I'd elect to install a new retainer bolt, but we rarely have one at hand when we're trying to finish up a job.

Because these four gears don't spin fast enough to make noise, and because they see so little wear, I would feel comfortable harvesting replacements at a salvage yard. There are three different axles listed for your truck. Replacing these gears is on the most common axle that has been used since forever by the big three manufacturers. The larger axle has eight bolts at the end of the housing, right in the middle of the center hole for the wheel. With that style, once the eight bolts are removed, you can slide the axle shaft out without removing the wheel / tire, and without even removing the differential cover. If you have that style, I'll have to format the procedure and post the steps for you. Also, if you have a locking differential, there will be a stack of clutch plates between the two axle gears. Special tools are needed to take that one apart, but I can post the instructions too.

Let me know if I missed anything or if you have questions.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
+1
Saturday, November 4th, 2023 AT 11:09 PM
Tiny
CARADIODOC
  • MECHANIC
  • 33,870 POSTS
I see Joe is on the ball and posted another dandy reply already. I'll gladly wait to see how this turns out and jump in only if you guys need more of my wondrous wisdom.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Saturday, November 4th, 2023 AT 11:12 PM
Tiny
BILL MARSHALL
  • MEMBER
  • 28 POSTS
Thank you both for the reply. My apologies for the delayed response, it's been a busy week.

Joe,

I knew the rear diffs failing were a pretty common issue on the Police Pursuit Vehicle (PPV) Tahoe's since I wanted to get an out-of-service PPV at first and I watched/read a ton of reviews and "before you buy" videos. I saw one where a guy had just gotten his PPV delivered from the auction and his first time behind the wheel, he does a burnout for the camera and blows the diff. Those trucks have a lot of hard miles on them though, I didn't think the regular production vehicles would have the same issue. Thank you for the pics/instructions.

Caradiodoc,

Wow. Thank you for the indepth write-up. I appreciate you taking the time to give a full walkthrough. It doesn't have a full floating axle and it does have rear disc brakes. I know it has 3.73 gears from the GT4 option code on the SPID sticker. I don't have opt G80 (LSD) or G81 (Locking diff) either. I am a firm believer in setting the parking brake when on an incline or decline as I know the parking pawl inside the trans is really the only thing keeping the truck from moving when in park, however, the truck only moves about an inch, if that, when parked at an angle without the brake set so I think the pinion shaft to housing clearance should be ok. As I know absolutely zero about setting backlash, I would much rather not start taking it apart to replace the spider gears and find out that it does need more items replaced and a complete tear down.

That being said, I think replacing the full axle assembly at once would be the better (easier) option. I have a few questions though.

1) Can I use a rear axle from a 2wd if it has the same 3.73 gears. It should be the same as the 4wd version, right?

2) Can I use a rear axle from a truck that has Active Brake Control (opt JL4) since mine does not?

In my search for a full rear assembly, I've noticed the availability of the 2x4 with GT4, as well as the 4x4 with GT4 and JL4 is much higher than the 4x4 with GT4 and without JL4. Also, they are much cheaper. In some cases, there's a $500 - $800 difference, my specific one being the higher priced.

Thank you for all your help.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Sunday, November 12th, 2023 AT 8:15 AM
Tiny
CARADIODOC
  • MECHANIC
  • 33,870 POSTS
Now you're in an area not of my expertise. I have a mental block when it comes to code numbers. I tend to go by application instead, and for an axle, I would let the guys at the salvage yards tell me which are the right ones.

I can see where the axle and spider gears could get stressed on a police car. I don't think that would affect the ring and pinion gears the same way. Afterall, they're designed to hold up to pulling a heavy trailer, and again, those smaller gears don't really do anything of significance when the axle is under load.

My plan of attack would be to replace the axle and spider gears. I'd suggest there's a 95 percent chance that will be the end of the story. If you do prefer to replace the entire axle, besides the gear ratio, you also must look if they mount the same to the control arms and springs, and if the universal joint is the same size and it needs the same length driveshaft.

The most overlooked variable is the size of the brake caliper or wheel cylinder, and rotors or drums. Those dimensions were carefully selected in the design to provide balanced braking, front to rear. This is a bigger concern with trucks. With many car models, there was only one axle choice. With trucks, many axles interchange from 1500s to 3500s, but that just means they will bolt in. The wheel stud pattern has to match, and you don't want to change anything regarding the stopping power of the brakes.

Joe will likely have some wondrous comments related to this too. Hopefully he can address the Active Brake Control system.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Monday, November 13th, 2023 AT 5:10 PM

Please login or register to post a reply.

Sponsored links