SPONSORED LINKS

Can removing the gearbox from Opel Astra G 2002 model cause damage to the Crown wheel bearings?

Tiny
NOUXOID
  • MEMBER
  • 2002 OPEL ASTRA
  • 59,000 MILES
My opel made a "release bearing" noise when I release the clutch, a type of grinding noise. Took it to repair place, was charged R5100 (around 660 USD, I'm in south africa), because the release bearing, clutch and pressure plate was replaced. After the parts were in they took it for a test drive, and in not even 15 meters (less than a mile, around.009 miles) something broke that made a whole in the sump, they thought it was the gearbox, but it turned out that it was a crown wheel bearing that collapsed, based on further investigation, after removing and stripping gearbox (for which I was charged aswell).
Repairs was done, mechanic said its not their fault. I don't know a lot about car workings in general, but would really really appreciate some advise or comments to clear things up. Was it their fault or could it just have happened anyway, a technical specialist was called in who said the gearbox is in perfect condition.

Currently I'm being charged an additional R5700 (around 799usd) for the replacement of crown wheel bearings.

Please any input greatly appreciated.
Thanks
Arno.
SPONSORED LINKS
Monday, October 31st, 2011 AT 6:19 PM

15 Replies

Tiny
MHPAUTOS
  • MECHANIC
  • 31,937 POSTS
Unfortunately these things can just be a coincidence, there is nothing that could have gone wrong with the installation of the clutch that would cause the bearing to fail so soon, I do feel that it was going to happen regardless of what was done, with out actually seeing all the damage first hand, this is the best explanation I can offer now.
SPONSORED LINKS
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Monday, October 31st, 2011 AT 9:21 PM
Tiny
FIXITMR
  • MECHANIC
  • 9,990 POSTS
Crown wheel means "ring gear" and pinion which part of differential drive. On rear wheel drive cars this seperate from transmission. On front wheel drive it is intergrated into transmission. However, just changing clutch and it's parts d should not effect the differential. Unless they forgot to put fluid back in if it was drained during change.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Tuesday, November 1st, 2011 AT 4:33 AM
Tiny
NOUXOID
  • MEMBER
  • 7 POSTS
Orite, thanks very much for your response. I forgot to add that the car still has the very same grinding noise when releasing the clutch, is this supposed to be the case, or could something else be the problem.

Thank you
Arno.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Tuesday, November 1st, 2011 AT 5:14 AM
Tiny
NOUXOID
  • MEMBER
  • 7 POSTS
Thank-you for the response, a friend of mine mentioned that it could be that they forgot the fluid. It is just very peculiar that it would break just after the car was worked on. Plus the sound with the release bearing that is still there also boggles my mind a bit.

The pics is that of my damaged sump and crown wheel.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Tuesday, November 1st, 2011 AT 5:42 AM
Tiny
MHPAUTOS
  • MECHANIC
  • 31,937 POSTS
Even with no oil it would not fail that quick if the distance you mentioned is correct, there should be no thrust bearing noise at all, the pic you mentioned has not loaded up, I can't see it.
SPONSORED LINKS
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Tuesday, November 1st, 2011 AT 6:49 AM
Tiny
NOUXOID
  • MEMBER
  • 7 POSTS
Thanks for all the input guys, really much appreciated, helps a lot.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Tuesday, November 1st, 2011 AT 8:24 AM
Tiny
FIXITMR
  • MECHANIC
  • 9,990 POSTS
Get those pics uploaded again. Make sure they are in the right format and size.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Tuesday, November 1st, 2011 AT 9:05 PM
Tiny
FIXITMR
  • MECHANIC
  • 9,990 POSTS
Does the grinding noise happen even if the trans is in neutral? Is it constant while car is running?
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Wednesday, November 2nd, 2011 AT 5:55 AM
Tiny
NOUXOID
  • MEMBER
  • 7 POSTS
Pics are in jpeg format, problem could be that I'm uploading with my HTC flyer, but anyways I tried again with a different browser so hoping it works.

The grinding noise is definitely there while car is idling in neutral, I can even feel the vibration on my foot while its on the clutch. Mechanic said that the previous release bearing and clutch were warn, but even after putting in new parts the noise remains. Could it be the flywheel? I'm just guessing, because it can only come from something that was not replaced, right?
Images (Click to make bigger)
Thumb
Thumb
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
+2
Wednesday, November 2nd, 2011 AT 6:41 AM
Tiny
FIXITMR
  • MECHANIC
  • 9,990 POSTS
Seems strange that 59000 miles and carrier bearings go out? And why the mechanic has no clue as to what it is/could be? Does it go away when you hold clutch to floor in neutral?
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
+1
Wednesday, November 2nd, 2011 AT 9:12 AM
Tiny
NOUXOID
  • MEMBER
  • 7 POSTS
The sound is completely gone when I press the clutch in, checked it now 10 minutes ago.
Will be taking the Astra in on Thursday for another look-over. Should be interesting.
While I'm driving the car the sound is there, or at least I'm pretty sure its there, cause the normal engine makes it a bit of a sound too ofcourse. But I'm 85 % sure of it cause I know my car.
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Wednesday, November 2nd, 2011 AT 3:35 PM
Tiny
FIXITMR
  • MECHANIC
  • 9,990 POSTS
Did they completely R&R the trans when they did crown repair? If those bearings were bad there may be more bad bearings in other sections of gear box?
SPONSORED LINKS
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Wednesday, November 2nd, 2011 AT 5:36 PM
Tiny
FIXITMR
  • MECHANIC
  • 9,990 POSTS
Might have been better to just get another used trans instead of trying to fix that 1? Unless they are known to fail so early!
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Wednesday, November 2nd, 2011 AT 5:51 PM
Tiny
NOUXOID
  • MEMBER
  • 7 POSTS
An RMI (retail motor industry) approved technical expert inspected the gearbox and said it was in perfect condition, couldn't find a thing wrong. But I've attached some more pics of the gearbox which is how far he got with inspecting it, not sure if that would have given him a proper view of the bearings.
Will update post again tomorrow,
-thanks
Images (Click to make bigger)
Thumb
Thumb
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Wednesday, November 2nd, 2011 AT 7:35 PM
Tiny
FIXITMR
  • MECHANIC
  • 9,990 POSTS
Did he have an explanation for why crown bearings went out?
Was this
answer
helpful?
Yes
No
Thursday, November 3rd, 2011 AT 1:53 AM

Please login or register to post a reply.

Related Wheel Bearing Replace/Remove Content

Wheel Bearing Replacement
VIDEO
Wheel Bearing Replacement
Instructional repair video
CV Axle Bearing Press
GUIDE
CV Axle Bearing Press
This guide will show you how to use a hydraulic press to install an axle bearing into a spindle which holds a CV axle on either the front or rear of your vehicle. We are a...

Sponsored links